In the News: How the After-Birth Abortion Study Trivialises Actual Abortion.

I don’t put a huge value on life.

Let me clarify: while I value my own life and the lives of my friends and families and try to make them as meaningful, pain-free and just as I can, I don’t see death as the big bad thing it’s made out to be. I don’t have a problem with suicide or euthanasia; if someone deems their own life not worth living due to (mental or physical) illness, then that’s their prerogative. When someone dies, it is sad, but it allows a new life to be created. These opinions won’t win me any friends, but they’re mine and I own them.

But when a study was published last week claiming that mentally newborn babies and foetuses have the same non-conceptualisation of their lives, I was outraged.

Abortion is my pet issue. I will attend rallies, talk and blog about it til the cows come home in an attempt to make sure abortion is available to all women all the time, no questions asked. I don’t believe a foetus is a life until it can survive outside the womb independently of its mother, therefore it doesn’t really apply to my above notions. To give it the same rights as a living, breathing person who is completely viable outside of its host human is insane. (Only in the U.S. does an embryo get more rights than most other people who live on this planet and not in the womb.) Once it’s outside of the womb it’s a human being, in my opinion (and those of most medical practitioners), not one minute before. That’s when the above notions apply.

But to insinuate that a zygotic blob taking up residence in another person’s body and a living, breathing, crying baby that has emerged from said other person’s body as a fully-fledged human are essentially the same and should be “aborted” with reckless abandon is an insult to anyone who’s had an abortion or believes in the right to have one. It trivialises the very real plight of women who find themselves pregnant when they really don’t want to be.

Because of my above views, some people think it’s okay to say things like “Justin Bieber should have been aborted” to me, when the topic of Bieber’s personal views on abortion comes up. While I don’t particularly like Bieber, using abortion as a retaliation for his small-minded views is abhorrent and, again, trivialises the process women who don’t want biological children (at that time or ever) have to go through. It’s not exactly easy, and women lucky enough to have access to reproductive healthcare shouldn’t be shamed or joked about because of it.

Have you read the study? What do you think of equating newborns with foetuses?

Elsewhere: [Sydney Morning Herald] “After Birth” Abortion Outrage.

[Jezebel] 6 Reasons Justin Bieber is Qualified to Talk About Abortion.

One thought on “In the News: How the After-Birth Abortion Study Trivialises Actual Abortion.

  1. I just read the article on this issue and it makes me sick to my stomach.
    I am pro-choice (for my own life however I am Pro-life) but to kill a human being. A living, breathing person who cannot decide for themselves is just wrong.
    I support Euthanasia if it is CHOSEN by the said person. I hate that suicide is so dominant in todays society but understand that some people do not see any other way but to to kill a baby… its Murder!
    I am outraged that people, doctors, educated adults who take the hippocratic oath to which states clearly “I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody if asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect” **
    ALL babies should have the chance to live… I know many people who try to have kids but cant and that baby could be loved and cherished… ALL babies deserved to be loved and cherished!

    (** I understand hypocrisy of my beliefs and this statement but the statement is a little outdated.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s