Katy P VS. Lady G.


Katy Perry burst onto our airwaves and TV screens in a blur of same-sex kisses and “cherry Chapstick” around the same time as Lady Gaga made her mark on the world with “Just Dance”. I had a preference for the former song at the time, however Gaga has proved she’s much more than a flash in the pan and has become one of my favourite artists, in pretty much every sense of the word.

Perry, on the other hand, is talked about more for her engagement to controversial comedian Russell Brand and star turn as Smurfette in the new Smurfs movie than for her singing talent.

No doubt she has a great voice, but her “Calfornia Gurls” video clip didn’t really live up to the hype, and it feels a bit forced.

Gaga’s clip for “Alejandro”, however, was more than I could’ve ever imagined it to be. Considering the song has an almost calypso vibe to it, I was expecting something more along the lines of her mediocre clip for the equally mediocre “Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say).” Granted, it was only her third single, and her record label was trying to push a mainstream image of her as opposed to the eccentric megastar we know her as today.

The highly sexualised and borderline blasphemous video evokes tones of Madonna’s “Like a Prayer”, “Rain”, “Vogue” and “Human Nature” as well as her film Evita. There are also references to Cabaret and Joan of Arc, in the red and white habit she wears. While I think it is an awesome and quite moving video that will stand the test of time, I admit Gaga has drawn a lot of her material for it from the one she is so often compared to, Madonna. I’ve never really noticed it before now…

It is certainly “like an 8+ minute homage to Madonna… with some gay Nazis thrown in for good measure”, according to the National Post, and even though director Steven Klein defended the video from religious groups, saying, “The religious symbolism is not meant to denote anything negative, but represents the character’s battle between the dark forces of this world and spiritual salvation of the Soul. Thus at the end of the film, she chooses to be a nun… she is withdrawing her senses from the world of evil and going inward towards prayer and contemplation.”

But when Gaga herself says that the video is about “a celebration of my love and appreciation for the gay community,” which, to me, signals the “dark forces of this world” could perhaps be the views of the Church towards gays and that “withdrawing… from the world of evil” is moving away from the Church.

So is Katy Perry right when she Tweets, “Using blasphemy as entertainment is as cheap as a comedian telling a fart joke”? It may be right (in some peoples’ eyes; certainly not mine. I’m all for a bit of religious imagery to spice up a music video or two), but it’s also hypocritical.

Perry comes from a religious background, but surely that background should be null and void when she releases “I Kissed A Girl”, gets engaged to a former sex and drug addict, and whose latest video features her naked on a cloud of fairy floss, and then tries to comment on religious good taste. To borrow another quote from the National Post, “I’m not sure if the girl who’s lactating whipped cream in her latest video should be judging other people’s lack of taste.”

In her defence, Perry did take to the radio in response to the controversy, saying “sexuality [as per her videos] is not the same as spirituality [as in Gaga’s videos].”

As Celebitchy notes, Perry released her “California Gurls” video on the same day the “Alejandro” clip came out. Jealous, much?

Here is a juxtaposition of both lady’s clips, so you can decide who should win this war. Vote one, Lady Gaga!

The Debut: I Kissed a Girl VS. Just Dance.

Hot N Cold VS. Poker Face.

The Love Interest Cameo: Waking Up in Vegas with Joel Moore VS. Paparazzi with Alexander Skarsgard.

The Collaboration: If We Ever Meet Again with Timbaland VS. Telephone with Beyonce.

California Gurls VS. Alejandro.

Elsewhere: [National Post] Scandal Sheet: Lady Gaga’s “Alejandro” Debuts.

[MTV] Lady Gaga’s “Alejandro” Director Defends Video’s Religious Symbolism.

[MTV] Lady Gaga Offers “Alejandro” Video Sneak Peek on Larry King Live.

[Celebitchy] Katy Perry Says Lady Gaga’s “Alejandro” Video is “Blasphemy”.

15 thoughts on “Katy P VS. Lady G.

  1. Great post Scarlett. I was personally offended (in some respects) by gaga’s video, however, I know it is art and a form of creative expression so I didnt let it get to me, I like to think I have an open mind. However, I always wonder why its the christian churches that are most criticised. Certainly, some other faith groups have similar attitudes to certain topics (eg: homosexuality) that christian faiths do, however, they never speak out about them content in the fact that the Christian churches are doing all the standing-up.

    Then again, I dont think Katy Perry should be speaking out, as most religious groups would be just as offended by the whipped-cream shooting boobs. (BTW, What the?) Then again, it’s hollywood, what can we expect?

  2. Good point, Sarah.
    That is an interesting one to ponder, as there is so much contention regarding criticisms of other faiths, Islam in particular. It makes you wonder why Christianity is the scapegoat for all religious criticisms.
    As a religious woman, perhaps that is a blog post for you to consider, as I’m sure you’re more qualified to comment on that than I am.
    Again, I am not offended by any aspects of any of these videos, however I do have a problem with bad taste, and I feel that’s what “California Gurls” represents.
    You said, “it’s Hollywood, what can we expect?”, and you’re right. However, it seems we can only expect criticisms of Christianity, heterosexuality and only very recently, in very small steps, homosexuality. Perhaps it’s not Hollywood’s job to question these issues, but it’s certainly one way of getting the mainstream public to notice different ways of thinking about these things.
    And that sounds like a whole other blog post for me to consider ;).

  3. Pingback: Mag Cover of the Week. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  4. Pingback: On the Net: Seven Links in Heaven. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  5. Pingback: Music Videos: More Madonna. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  6. Pingback: On the Net: Like a Virgin, Take 2. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  7. Pingback: On the (Rest of the) Net. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  8. Pingback: Music Video: The Underlying Message in Madonna’s “Like a Prayer” Video. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  9. Pingback: Lady Gaga: Taking Inspiration from The Wizard of Oz. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  10. Pingback: UPDATED: Lady Gaga—Taking Inspiration from The Wizard of Oz. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  11. Pingback: Music Videos: Who’s the Copycat Now, Katy Perry? « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  12. Pingback: Battle of the Friday Anthems: Rebecca Black VS. Katy Perry. « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  13. Pingback: Gaga Ooo La La? « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

  14. Pingback: UPDATED: Gaga Ooo La La? « The Early Bird Catches the Worm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s